So I was using my Logitech G935 mic and it would record in my game recordings via Steam Record, Players in Arc Raiders could hear me and I could hear it in Windows 11 Sound settings.

I ended up buying an affordable MAONO Dynamic Gaming Microphone while on sale which sounds pretty good for the price point. I installed all the softward, tweaked the settings and set it as my default recording and communinations device.

Now, I can preview it in Windows 11 sound settings and it works, I preveiw it in Steam Mic Settings and it works and players in Arc Raiders can hear me fin but for some reason, my mic isn't being record via Steam Game Recording.

Tested even in OBS just to be sure, and works/records perfectly fine.

I spent the last hour trying different troubleshooting and I am out of ideas.